Bríd Mhór wrote:
Always willing to do a soundfile for somebody from Baile Liam
http://www.box.com/s/58bed2c82ca4e0183976That's nice, Bríd, but I would prefer to wait until we have settled on a correct translation on which three agree before moving on to the pronunciation, etc. Even if you agree with Caoimhín on all of the points above, that is still only two in agreement so far ...
CaoimhínSF wrote:
Quote:
gcroí
and each person having one heart.
I understand that as a general rule, but am not sure I entirely agree in this case, because there's a clear emphasis on the thing happening in their (multiple) hearts.
Two hearts as one - even more reason to go with the singular.
CaoimhínSF wrote:
Quote:
in bhur
Yes, I know that's technically the rule in writing, but not in speech, as you noted.
But in spoken Connemara dialect, more appropriate to Baile Liam,
in bhur gcroí would be
ina gcroí, which is "in our hearts", "in your (pl) hearts", and "in their hearts", and if it is considered necessary to distinguish further, then
sibh is added, as in
ina gcroí sibh:
So, it should be either
in bhur gcroí (standard) or
ina gcroí sibh (spoken) but I think
i bhur* is just mixed up.